Subscribe Twitter Redeemer City to City Facebook Share
Share on:
blog

The Big Issues facing the Western Church

11 Feb 2010, by Tim Keller

1. The opportunity for extensive culture-making in the U.S. In an interview, sociologist Peter Berger observed that in the U.S. evangelicals are shifting from being largely a blue-collar constituency to becoming a college educated population.

His question is--will Christians going into the arts, business, government, the media, and film a) assimilate to the existing baseline cultural narratives so they become in their views and values the same as other secular professionals and elites, or b) will they seal off and privatize their faith from their work so that, effectively, they do not do their work in any distinctive way, or c) will they do enough new Christian 'culture-making' in their fields to change things? (See http://www.virginia.edu/iasc/HHR_Archives/AfterSecularization/8.12PBerger.pdf)

2. The rise of Islam. How do Christians relate to Muslims when we live side by side in the same society? The record in places like Africa and the Middle East is not encouraging! This is more of an issue for the western church in Europe than in the U.S., but it is going to be a growing concern in America as well.

How can Christians be at the very same time a) good neighbors, seeking their good whether they convert or not, and still b) attractively and effectively invite Muslims to consider the gospel?

3. The new non-western Global Christianity. The demographic center of Christian gravity has already shifted from the west to Asia, Latin America, and Africa. The rising urban churches of China may be particularly influential in the future. But the west still has the educational institutions, the money, and a great deal of power.

What should the relationship of the older western churches be to the new non-western church? How can we use our assets to serve them in ways that are not paternalistic? How can we learn from them in more than perfunctory ways?

4. The growing cultural remoteness of the gospel.  The basic concepts of the gospel -- sin, guilt and accountability before God, the sacrifice of the cross, human nature, afterlife -- are becoming culturally strange in the west for the first time in 1500 years. As Lesslie Newbigin has written, it is time now to 'think like a missionary'--to formulate ways of communicating the gospel that both confront and engage our increasingly non-Christian western culture.

How do we make the gospel culturally accessible without compromising it? How can we communicate it and live it in a way that is comprehensible to people who lack the basic 'mental furniture' to even understand the essential truths of the Bible?

5. The end of prosperity? With the economic meltdown, the question is -- will housing values, endowments, profits, salaries, and investments go back to growing at the same rates as they have for the last twenty-five years, or will growth be relatively flat for many years to come? If so, how does the western church, which has become habituated to giving out of fast-increasing assets, adjust in the way it carries out ministry? For example, American ministry is now highly professionalized--church staffs are far larger than they were two generations ago, when a church of 1,000 was only expected to have, perhaps, two pastors and a couple of other part-time staff. Today such a church would have probably eight to ten full-time staff members.

Also, how should the stewardship message adjust? If discretionary assets are one-half of what they were, more risky, sacrificial giving will be necessary to do even less ministry than we have been doing.

On top of this, if we experience even one significant act of nuclear or bio-terrorism in the U.S. or Europe, we may have to throw out all the basic assumptions about social and economic progress we have been working off for the last 65 years. In the first half of the 20th century, we had two World Wars and a Depression. Is the church ready for that? How could it be? What does that mean?

Comments

RupZip
02/11/2010
I think we are seeing so many things 'blow up' in our face as the American church. We became so accessible and seeker kind, that we forgot to disciple and teach people. Now we have a generation of dumbed down Christians....which sets the stage for catasrophe. If we go into these things you outline above as weak Christians, how can we possibly affect the world with the Gospel? It's time to "gird up our loins!" Great analysis of the times! David Rupert Red Letter Believers Blog "Salt and Light" http://www.redletterbelievers.com

SteveLutz
02/11/2010
In addition to the 5 external issues mentioned above, I would add the following 2 internal issues, both of which are informed by my working with those who ARE the future of the church, college students: 1) the rapid hemorrhaging of Christians from the Church, especially our young adults. People often assume "they'll come back when they have kids" but that was a baby boomer phenomenon--there's no guarantee they will return. The Church's spiritual birthrate has been declining for some time, and we'll feel it as a crisis in the next 10-20 years, unless things change. 2) Ecclesiology. Megachurch, microchurch, organic church, house church, multisite church, parachurch, dying church--the lines are blurring and it all seems up for grabs. Much of this conversation will be fruitful as the church recontextualizes for a post-Christian west, but its also fraught with potential for remaking mistakes we've made in the past.

almost an M
02/11/2010
This is such a good list for awareness, discussion, and action. Thank you! On point #4, it is my belief and has been my experience that we must be about living a life transformed among the lost for them to get a glimpse of the difference between this world and the Kingdom of God. Through this, they desire to learn the "why" and "how" of the difference. This puts much (perhaps most) of discipleship on the front end of belief. The message of the gospel is communicated over time as people are disoriented enough to receive it. On point #5, you state: "If discretionary assets are one-half of what they were, more risky, sacrificial giving will be necessary to do even less ministry than we have been doing." I would suggest the addition of: ...to do even less ministry than we have been doing if we continue doing it in the same way.

brookshanes
02/12/2010
The church will thrive in not only persecution (which exists in times of trial) but also in times of radical cultural upheaval (brought about through war and terrorism). The true question is, "who is the church?" We must be ready to stare the culture in the eye and declare a new, (read: old), simple (read: ultimately difficult to accept), gospel. As prophetic as we like to think we are, nothing will be as we predict except hearts that reject God and God leading other hearts to accept him. In rural America we once "enjoyed" a 10-year-lag (which you have previously pithily predicted is shrinking in time) behind the left and right coasts. I am constantly barraged by people who seek to reach out to this slower culture but it seems the culture is ready to reject the gospel based upon European and big-city theories. This has never happened before in history: ideas are propagated into the cracks and crevices of our country with no one physically traveling to take the message there. I'm just dancing around in the thoughts your post gave me, but I believe the holistic approach to the gospel will make a come-back through each of your predictions in this article. No longer will anyone in the United States be able to hold to traditions of "let's go to church because it's the good thing to do" when their children on the home computer discover that "church is no longer what most people do." Instant effects as culture follows itself for culture's sake. One point I'll nail down with all I have, an "amen, amen" if you will, is the 800 pound gorilla sitting atop the megachurch steeple. It is difficult to stare a person in the eye in my town and tell him the best thing for the world is a large church. Church to them means a building. But a big Jesus is another thing to talk about, and building a large (read: continuously effective, growing gospel community) then starts to make sense. Kudos for throwing my brain into chaos!

ChristineSine
02/25/2010
I was interested to read this article as you cover many of the same issues that I have been thinking about. It really concerns me to see how few in the American church are grappling with these issues. I wrote a series of posts on my blog last month addressing many of these issues. The articles received quite a bit of attention but not nearly as much as an article I posted on Cage Fighting for Jesus which I found rather frustrating. You can check them out here http://godspace.wordpress.com/2010/01/28/religious-pluralism-how-will-it-shape-christian-faith/